نوع مقاله : علمی -پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسنده English
The problem of “prime matter” remains one of the most contentious and complex issues within Aristotelian physics and metaphysics. This article undertakes a rigorous internal critique of three primary contemporary approaches: the eliminativist stance (Charlton); the traditional approach which, by positing a pre-formal and universal matter for all things, entails a form of ontological independence (Robinson); and the reinterpretation of elements and matter (Sokolowski) that assigns a central role to corporeity and extension in explaining the constitution of elemental bodies, thereby attempting to render prime matter intelligible. This research demonstrates that while these frameworks attempt to resolve certain historical difficulties, they ultimately precipitate new conceptual crises. Specifically, the elimination of prime matter reduces substantial change to accidental alteration, while the postulation of pre-formal matter or the attribution of extension and corporeity to it contradicts the fundamental Aristotelian definition of matter as “pure potency.”Employing a methodological framework of textual analysis and internal dialectical critique, this paper proposes a “preferred approach.” It argues that prime matter should not be conceptualized as an independent substance, but rather as the “immanent modality of possibility” inherent within an actualized body. By grounding this interpretation in the principle of “potency” and the ontological primacy of actuality, the proposed model preserves the substantial unity of the composite while providing a coherent account of change, thereby circumventing the fundamental logical impasses inherent in competing contemporary interpretations.
کلیدواژهها English